Gimme Brow + Volumising Eyebrow Pencil 1.19g

I like and use other benefit brow products and I liked this product too. Until you have to sharpen it. When you attempt to sharpen this pencil, you're first able to remove the outside wood but then you encounter the plastic enclosed brown pencil. You cannot sharpen the plastic enclosure off. I used a standard pencil sharpener, a knife and a razor blade. The hard plastic removes but it take the pencil with it. Terrible for the money and a disappointment with benefit's design. I've attached what is left of this pencil after attempting to sharpen. It's almost comical.

I'm a natural redhead (copper shade) and its so hard to find a color that works for me. I was using #2 for a while, it just wasn't right but the closest i could get and i tried #3 but it wasn't right either. So here comes 2.5 and its perfect! I like this pencil version better than the automatic ones, it goes on and rakes through the brows effortlessly. Please keep this pencil around and don't change the colors or formula because it really is perfection.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The pigment is great, super soft and natural looking. I only using this from now on. Super recommend this. It looks really natural and it last a long time

Benefit, PLEASE never ever ever get rid of or discontinue this beloved product unfortunately, I don't have much brow at all. Just a few hairs on each side. When I tell you that I've tried every brow pencil and brow pen- I truly have and NOTHING has ever worked for me quite like this magical pencil this is the ONLY product that makes it look as though I have NATURAL beautiful brows. I've never seen anything else like this magical product in the market. I have ONLY used this beloved volumizing/fiber pencil since I got it when it first released. I love many of your products, but this pencil is by far my most favorite thing from your brand and one of my top HOLY GRAIL products in my day to day routine. I promise to be a customer forever- please never get rid of this magical formula! You truly are such an innovative brand. Love you guys so much!

I love this product! It comes with the pencil and a spoliy. It lasts all day with brow glue. It applies very smooth and gives a nice color. I totally recommend.

Would not recommend - same issue others have reported with the pencil keeps breaking off. Very frustrating

I love Benefit eye products. This brow pencil pulls out my brow hairs. I've used other brow pencils in between. When I return to this pencil I lose my brow.

I bought this pencil just before Christmas for £24.50. It is awful and does nothing for my brows and no colour. So I tried to sharpen it but it just keeps breaking so it is now unusable. An expensive pencil and a complete waste of money.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this product. It's natural and doesn't make your brows look fake. I will definitely recommend it to everyone. This is by far my favorite product.

My Black Friday steal; I love this product. It's easy to use and just the right amount of paint to creat a natural looking brow. I have light brows and needed something to darken them. There's no mess or need to be an expert. They help you color in the perfect brow. Will continue to buy them and hope they never discontinue the product. I partner it with benefit brow volumnizing gel and the result are natural looking brows.

I bought the pencil and when I tried to sharpen it, saw that the pencil would keep breaking because of the inner plastic coating which is very sturdy. It went from full size to a third of it before I could use some of the pencil. I did not keep proof of purchase and customer service cannot help.

This brow pencil works well for me. The gray is not too dark. Easy to apply.

Yes I would recommend the primer the mascara the pencil. Benefits cosmetics are by far the best I have ever used and believe me I used many different brands .

It's very easy to use and it's natural-looking and holds well. I like the precision that it has and don't forget to buy the sharpener. I love this product and it's great for beginners.