The ultimate guide to the best mince pies
Senior Food Editor
Heather TaylorWhat are the best mince pies for Christmas 2024?
Our talented chefs have tasted well over 150 mince pies to bring you a pie for every taste this year, trialling hundreds of pastry recipes and tweaking the fillings to get them just right. Every pie is packed with delicious additions, from the caramelised sugar in the pastry for our Collection Mince Pies to the crumbliest, richest vegan pastry in our Plant Kitchen Mince Pies. For those who aren’t mince pie purists, there are pies filled with sloe gin crumble, chocolatey pies adorned with Rodney Reindeer, and frangipane and-crumble-topped mince pies. Keep reading to discover what’s in store – all that’s needed is a steaming cup of mulled wine and a dollop of brandy butter.
The best all-butter mince pies
We’ve improved the recipe for our award-winning Collection Mince Pies this year to create mince pie perfection. Caramelised sugar in the pastry creates a rich, nutty flavour. They're also made with Wildfarmed flour, which supports biodiversity on British farmlands. The melt-in-the-mouth pastry is deep-filled with our exclusive-recipe mincemeat, bursting with vine fruits, glacé cherries, brandy, cider, clementine juice and cognac. Plus, this year, we’ve added a secret ingredient that gives it an extra warming kick – can you guess what it is? Finally, we’ve updated the design to a beautiful kaleidoscope-inspired pastry top that echoes the stunning packaging.
The best vegan mince pies
Going plant-based shouldn’t mean missing out on the quintessential Christmas treat. Our Plant Kitchen Mince Pies are made with a rich, indulgent vegan pastry that’s generously filled with our classic recipe mincemeat, bursting with fruits and festive spice. For best results, briefly warm these in the oven.
The best gluten-free mince pies
Searching for a gorgeous gluten-free mince pie? We’ve got you. Our Made Without Wheat Mince Pies are made with a crumbly, all-butter gluten-free pastry that’s filled with our classic mincemeat, spiced with dried vine fruits like Vostizza currants, sultanas and raisins, and candied peel. They’re topped with a festive pastry star and a dusting of icing sugar and taste wonderful warm.
The best mince pies for families
Don’t fancy traditional mincemeat, or want something the whole family can enjoy? Our viral Rodney Reindeer Pies are back and better than ever this Christmas. They’re made with an irresistible brown butter pastry, which has a nutty, rich flavour, filled with moreish Belgian milk chocolate brownie. A super cute Rodney Reindeer pastry face makes them too cute to save for Santa.
The best frangipane, crumble-and buttercream-topped mince pies
Our chefs have created three wow-worthy toppings for our Collection mince pies this year. There’s a rich, indulgent swirl of brandy buttercream crowning our Collection Brandy Butter Mince Pies, which taste like a mince pie with a dollop of brandy butter in one. Our Collection Frangipane Mince Pies are topped with a soft almond frangipane and flaked almonds, and our Sloe Gin Crumble Mince Pies have a rubbly, crunchy crumble and sloe gin and cranberries spiking the traditional juicy mincemeat filling. They’re all made with our signature Collection all-butter pastry with caramelised sugar and Wildfarmed flour.
The best mince pie… in a glass!
Introducing everything you love about mince pies in boozy, drinkable form. Our Mince Pie Liqueur has all the flavours of a mince pie – from buttery pastry to rich, spiced fruits. Plus, it comes in a magical light-up bottle. It’s heaven sipped over ice (ideally alongside your favourite mince pie) or, to make an instant-but-epic festive dessert, pour it over vanilla ice cream.
The best mince pie recipes
Whether you fancy making a traditional homemade mince pie (we like ours with a zesty marmalade glaze) or just want to inject the flavours of mince pies into everything from a giant clotted cream pancake to a Christmas tree, our festive mince pie-inspired recipes have got you covered.
Published 11.4.2024
Related Stories
Christmas sarnies, snacks and more
Enjoy festive flavour on the go with our lineup of epic Christmas sandwiches, rolls, wraps and snacks. Discover the range and learn more about our charity partnership with Shelter.
Tuck in
Seriously tasty Secret Santa gifts
Taking part in Secret Santa this year and not sure what to buy? From seriously tasty snacks – ideal for the office cupboard raider – to wonderful wines, now’s the time to find a goodie that’s almost too good to gift. Scroll to see a few of our favourites.
Pick a pressie
Top advent calendars this Christmas
Whether you’re shopping for a Percy super fan or someone who enjoys a festive tipple or two, you’ll find the perfect advent calendar for a loved one (or yourself) this Christmas in our Foodhall. Explore our top picks below to make the countdown to the big day extra sweet.
See the top picks
Christmas liqueurs and spirits guide
Raise the bar this season with our expert pick of the best Christmas spirits, from gins, rum and small-batch vodka to must-try sweet liqueurs. Whether you’re searching for a great bottle to bring as a gift, or want to shake up some special cocktails for your party guests, these unique-to-M&S drinks are guaranteed to get you into the seasonal spirit.
See the picks